Universal Kernel

The twenty-eight

Stabilizer S3S_3, rigid: the antiflags, pairs, Sylow 3-subgroups, bitangents and Coxeter vertices are one object, with exactly one seam between any two.

{0, ∞}(1, 246)d0⟨z ↦ 2z⟩

Projective line

a 2-subset of P1(F7)

0123456∞

Fano plane

an antiflag (p, L), p ∉ L

1234567

Graphs

a vertex of the Coxeter graph

The group

a Sylow 3-subgroup of PSL(2,7)

generator
z ↦ 2z
on the eight points
(1 2 4)(3 6 5)
fixes
{0, ∞}, and nothing else

Klein quartic

a bitangent of x³y + y³z + z³x = 0

the line
x + y + z = 0
touching
at (1 : ω : ω²) and (1 : ω² : ω), the two points fixed by ρ of the subgroup

Choose a vertex of the Coxeter graph, or step through all twenty-eight.

One element of the object, in five incarnations at once. The pair, the antiflag, the vertex and the subgroup are matched by the volume’s table and the seams of S3S_3; vertex names follow Coxeter’s labelling under one chosen isomorphism, and another marking would relabel them. Blue chords and ink edges are the element’s three neighbours in the Coxeter graph.

Its incarnations

The seam table names the object in each of the five theories that meet the group. Every entry there is built.

Fano plane
antiflags
Projective line
2-subsets; perfect matchings in the orbit of {01,23,45,6∞}\{01,23,45,6\infty\}
The group
subgroups of order 3; of order 6
Klein quartic
bitangents; their poles
Graphs
Coxeter vertices; Heawood hexagons

The stabilizer is its own normalizer, so between any two incarnations there is exactly one seam, and the seams agree.

The fifteen objects

168184C256C324C742C41G28S3anchored observers14A4b7S4bvantage lines7S4aclocks14A4a21D842V4b42V4a87:3the sky
The object on the line of sizes. In ink, the objects it maps onto; in blue, those that map onto it. Dots count each object’s automorphisms, and dashed brackets join the pairs with one permutation character.
Theorem(The twenty-eight)

Up to isomorphism, G=PSL⁡(2,7)G=\PSL(2,7) has exactly one object with 28 elements. It is rigid, and its stabilizer class is fixed by Aut⁡(G)\Aut(G). Consequently, between any two transitive GG-sets with 28 elements there is exactly one seam, and these seams are consistent, sjk∘sij=siks_{jk}\circ s_{ij}=s_{ik}; and for any two transitive permutation groups of degree 28 isomorphic to GG, the permutation isomorphisms between them correspond bijectively to the isomorphisms between the groups, and there are 336 of them.

Proof

An object with 28 elements has stabilizers of order 6. The 56 elements of order 3 form one class with centralizers of order 3, so there are 28 Sylow 3-subgroups with normalizers S3S_3, and every subgroup of order 6 is the normalizer of its unique subgroup of order 3. These form the unique class of subgroups of order 6, which every automorphism fixes, and each is self-normalizing.

Example

Its five incarnations: the pairs of P1(F7)\Proj^1(\F_7); the Sylow 3-subgroups under conjugation; the antiflags of the Fano plane; the bitangents of the Klein quartic; the vertices of the Coxeter graph. The unique seam from the Sylow subgroups sends PP to the one point it fixes: the pair of points fixed by PP, the point and the line fixed by it, the line through its two fixed points on the curve, the vertex it fixes. So the pair {0,∞}\{0,\infty\}, the subgroup ⟨z↦2z⟩\langle z\mapsto2z\rangle and the bitangent x+y+z=0x+y+z=0 are one element.

Proposition(The Coxeter graph is intrinsic)

The point stabilizers have orbits of lengths 1,3,3,3,6,6,6. Exactly three orbital graphs are cubic: two are disjoint unions of seven K4K_4’s, and the third is connected and is the Coxeter graph, so every seam carries it. On the pairs, {a,b}\{a,b\} and {c,d}\{c,d\} are adjacent when they are disjoint and (a,b;c,d)=−1(a,b;c,d)=-1; on the antiflags, (p,L)(p,L) and (q,M)(q,M) are adjacent when p≠qp\neq q, L≠ML\neq M, p∉Mp\notin M and q∉Lq\notin L, equivalently when the triangles they leave over are disjoint; on the Sylow subgroups, PP and QQ are adjacent when tutu has order 4 for all elements t∈Pt\in P and u∈Qu\in Q of order 3.

Remark(Points and lines inside the twenty-eight)

The two families of K4K_4’s are the two ways the object sees the objects of size 7: the antiflags with a common point, and those with a common line. Which family is the points depends on the marking, and z↦3zz\mapsto3z exchanges them. Two Coxeter-adjacent bitangents meet at one of the 21 centres of involutions; four bitangents pass through each centre, and the two elements of order 4 fixing it pair them into the two Coxeter edges there. The normalizer of GG in the symmetric group of the 28 points has order 336, and in the pairs it is PGL⁡(2,7)\PGL(2,7).

Further incarnations: the subgroups of order 6; the poles of the bitangents, such as (1:1:1)(1:1:1); the hexagons of the Heawood graph; the perfect matchings of P1(F7)\Proj^1(\F_7) in the orbit of {01,23,45,6∞}\{01,23,45,6\infty\}; the 28 ideal edges of Thurston’s congruence link complement; and the pairs of vertices at distance 3 in the link at 2, or of neighbours in the link at 7. The 28 ideal tetrahedra of the same manifold are not this object: that bridge is refuted.

Open questionopen

Describe the Coxeter adjacency on the 28 bitangents in the projective geometry of the quartic alone, without naming group elements; and give a conceptual reason why the Coxeter edges are the pairs of Sylow 3-subgroups whose elements of order 3 multiply to elements of order 4.

Theorem(One lattice, three completions) computed

In Klein’s lattice, the unimodular hermitian lattice of rank 3 over Z[(−1+−7)/2]\Z[(-1+\sqrt{-7})/2] on which the group acts, the 28 pairs of vectors of norm 3 reduce at the prime 2 to the antiflags of a Fano plane, at −7\sqrt{-7} to the pairs of points of the sky, and in Klein’s plane, through v↦v⊥v\mapsto v^\perp, to the bitangents of the Klein quartic. The maps commute with the group, so they are the seams between the three incarnations.

Remark

In the Weil representation of SL⁡(2,7)\SL(2,7) two families of algebras su(3)\mathfrak{su}(3), one over each pair of points, belong to the octonion table and to its mirror; both are incarnations of this object, so the seam between them is unique, and over each pair it is conjugation by the polarity of the Fano plane that fixes the pair. Transporting the first family between pairs that share a point gives a flat connection on the complex of stars whose holonomy is all of the stabilizer of a pair and acts by inner automorphisms.

Examplecomputed

At Klein’s lattice the antiflags are vectors: the 28 pairs of vectors of norm 3 are the four diagonals u1±u2±u3u_1\pm u_2\pm u_3 of the cubes at the neighbours of the lattice, and the Coxeter graph is an inner-product graph, with ∣h(w,w′)∣2|h(w,w')|^2 equal to 7, 4, 2, 1 at Coxeter distance 1, 2, 3, 4. Coxeter neighbours are orthogonal modulo −7\sqrt{-7}, not in the lattice.

Examplecomputed

In the lattice Herm2(Z[ω])\mathrm{Herm}_2(\Z[\omega]) with the form det⁡\det, the records gg†gg^\dagger, g∈SL⁡(2,Z[ω])g\in\SL(2,\Z[\omega]), form 28 classes modulo Γ(p)\Gamma(\mathfrak p), p=(3+ω)\mathfrak p=(3+\omega). Splitting a record into its two primitive null vectors and reducing their cusps modulo p\mathfrak p is an equivariant bijection from these classes onto the 28 pairs of points of P1(F7)\Proj^1(\F_7): the object of size 28 is a set of classes of rest frames, the edges of the tessellation of H3\mathbb H^3, each the geodesic joining two cusps.

Its names

Each row is a marked set: a theory’s figures, with GG acting through the marking named. The seam from the Sylow subgroups sends a subgroup PP of order 3 to the one point it fixes. Every bridge here is built: an explicit equivariant map.

TheoryThe 28 thereThe image of PPStatus
Projective line2-subsets of P1(F7)\Proj^1(\F_7)marked by the Möbius action itselfthe two points of P1(F7)\Proj^1(\F_7) fixed by PPbuilt
The groupSylow 3-subgroups of PSL⁡(2,7)\PSL(2,7), under conjugationmarked by none neededPP itselfbuilt
Fano planeantiflags (p,L)(p,L) of PG(2,2)\mathrm{PG}(2,2), p∉Lp\notin Lmarked by an isomorphism μA ⁣:G→GL⁡(3,2)\mu_A\colon G\to\GL(3,2)the unique point and the unique line fixed by μA(P)\mu_A(P)built
Klein quarticbitangents of x3y+y3z+z3x=0x^3y+y^3z+z^3x=0marked by Klein’s representation ρ\rhothe line through the two points of the curve fixed by ρ(P)\rho(P)built
Graphsvertices of the Coxeter graphmarked by an isomorphism μC\mu_C onto the derived subgroupthe unique vertex fixed by μC(P)\mu_C(P)built

The structure every incarnation carries

A point stabilizer has orbits of lengths 1,3,3,3,6,6,6 on the object. Exactly three of the group’s orbital graphs on it are cubic: two are disjoint unions of seven copies of K4K_4, and the third is connected and is the Coxeter graph. Every seam carries one to the other, so the Coxeter graph is intrinsic to the object, and each incarnation sees it in its own terms:

  • on the projective line, two pairs {a,b}\{a,b\}, {c,d}\{c,d\} are adjacent when they are disjoint and the cross-ratio (a,b;c,d)(a,b;c,d) is −1-1;
  • in the Fano plane, (p,L)(p,L) and (q,M)(q,M) are adjacent when p≠qp\neq q, L≠ML\neq M, p∉Mp\notin M and q∉Lq\notin L, equivalently when the triangles they leave over are disjoint;
  • in the group, PP and QQ are adjacent when tutu has order 4 for all elements t∈Pt\in P and u∈Qu\in Q of order 3.
Remark(points and lines inside the twenty-eight)

The two families of K4K_4’s are the two ways in which the object of size 28 sees the objects of size 7: the antiflags with a common point, and those with a common line. On the projective line each K4K_4 is four disjoint pairs covering P1(F7)\Proj^1(\F_7). Which family belongs to the points depends on the marking: the map z↦3zz\mapsto3z, outside GG, induces an outer automorphism and exchanges the two families.

The volume’s word
anchored observerliftrecord